Should You Buy a Blackstone Griddle? Pros, Cons & What to Cook
Flat-top griddles are everywhere right now, and customers keep asking us if they are worth it. Here is an honest, butcher's-eye breakdown of where a Blackstone shines, where it falls short, and what to throw on it.
Flat-top griddles have taken over backyards, and barely a week goes by without someone at the counter asking whether they should get one. The honest answer: a griddle is a fantastic tool for a specific kind of cooking — just not a replacement for your grill. Here is how we think about it.
The case for a griddle
The Pros
- Unbeatable for smash burgers — the flat steel gives that lacy, crispy crust you cannot get on a grate
- Huge, even cooking surface for feeding a crowd breakfast: bacon, eggs, hashbrowns, and links all at once
- Perfect for foods that fall through grill grates — diced vegetables, shrimp, smaller cuts, fried rice
- Fast to preheat and easy to cook on; great for weeknight dinners
- Edge-to-edge consistent temperature once you learn the zones
The Cons
- No live-fire char or smoke flavor — a griddle sears, but it will never taste like charcoal
- You cannot cook thick, indirect items like ribs or a whole chicken well
- Seasoning and rust management is real maintenance — it needs care like a cast iron pan
- Takes up significant space and is not very portable
- Grease management can be messy if you let it build up
What it is genuinely great at
A griddle earns its keep at breakfast and at burger night. There is no better surface for a big weekend breakfast — lay down bacon and breakfast links on one side, crack eggs on the other, and crisp hashbrowns in the rendered fat. For dinner, smash burgers are the killer app: a screaming-hot flat top is the only way to get that crispy, craggy edge.
Regular Bacon
Our house bacon renders beautifully on a flat top — and that fat is your cooking oil for everything else.
Breakfast Links
Breakfast links brown evenly across the whole surface — perfect for cooking for a crowd.
So, should you buy one?
If you already have a grill and love big breakfasts, smash burgers, or cooking for groups, a griddle is a joyful addition. If you are choosing your one and only outdoor cooker and you crave smoke and char, get a good charcoal grill first. For most backyards, the dream setup is both — a charcoal grill for fire and flavor, and a griddle for volume and versatility.
Our take
A griddle is a "second cooker" that punches above its weight. It will not replace your grill or smoker, but it will absolutely earn a spot in the rotation.
Keep Reading
Grilling TipsHow to Set Up a Charcoal BBQ: A Pitmaster's Starter Guide
Gas is convenient, but charcoal is flavor. If you have ever struggled to light coals or burned everything to a crisp, these counter-tested tips will turn your kettle into a reliable cooking machine.
Read more
SpecialsThe 250 oz Butcher's Select Huddle: Our Pack for America's 250th
America turns 250, so we built a 250-ounce tailgate pack to match. Steaks, burgers, brats, dogs, and jerky — one box, built to feed the whole huddle. Here is what is inside and how to cook it.
Read more
RecipesWild Sockeye Is Back: Five Ways to Cook It This Summer
Our deep-red, line-caught sockeye has landed for the season. It is lean, rich, and forgiving on the grill if you treat it right. Here are five simple ways to put it on the table.
Read more